Archive for June 21st, 2007

Which University to recommend for central university status?

Pragativadi reports that the central government has sent a proposal asking which university in the state it wants to be recommended as a central university. Following are some excerpts from that report.

The Centre has yet again proposed the state government to identify one of the universities of the state to be accorded with Central University status.

A letter from the Union HRD ministry to the state government has assured that the Centre would provide cent percent financial assistance for converting any one of the state universities into a Central University. …

Meanwhile, the state higher education department, that has received the recent letter from the HRD ministry, is reviewing its consideration it had taken earlier. Sources in the official circles however, said that the state government is in a fix to recommend the name of the university to obtain central varsity status.

My initial take on this is that the state government pick one of its current university, but say in the letter that  in view of the necessity of a central university in KBK, the picked university will have to have branch campuses across KBK and thus will need adequate funding for that. The long term goal then would be to convert the KBK branch campuses to a separate central university at an appropriate time in the future.

13 comments June 21st, 2007

Orissa JEE has released additional rankings

The Orissa JEE has come out with an additional list and ranking of students beyond the initial 21455 ranks. See details in the Orissa JEE page. Here is what it says:

ATTENTION: ORISSA JEE 07 APPEARED CANDIDATES FOR ENGINEERING STREAM ADDITIONAL LIST of QUALIFIED CANDIDATES in ENGINEERING for ADMISSION into PRIVATE COLLEGES only.
The ORISSA JEE qualified candidates featuring in this additional list ( i.e. starting from Rank No. 21546 downwards ) will have to seek admission through the College Level only and not through the centralized counseling-cum-admission process of the JEE – 07.

New Indian Express has a nice report on this with additional information.

43 comments June 21st, 2007

Rejoinder to Mr. Jairam Ramesh’s comments in Bhubaneswar on the IIT Orissa issue

Dear Mr. Ramesh:

I read about your visit to Bhubaneswar and some news reports and quotes of yours in Statesman. (See article below.)

1. One of them says:

“I do not want to score political points but what if I ask what were these people doing in all the six years that the NDA was in power. The IIT could have come up in six years time , what were you (the BJD) doing when all that you needed was to take up the file to Mr Vajpayee and he would have signed it,” shot back Mr Ramesh.

2. Another paragraph of that report says:

Repeatedly emphasising that he was one with the demand of the state for institutes of higher education, Mr Ramesh said at the same time, one should realise that an IIT will solve the problem of unemployment. Has Kanpur IIT contributed in any way to Kanpur? In fact, IITs have contributed more to the US economy than Indian economy, he remarked.

===

Mr. Ramesh: I don’t know if your intent was to score political points or if this is your thinking. You are quoted as saying that “you do not want to score political points”, so these must be your real views.
(1′) Your comment (1) implies that a state can get an IIT (or similar institute) only when its coalition is in power in Delhi. Do you really mean that? So is the UPA government in Delhi only for states with UPA friendly governments and the rest should go to hell in regards to higher education institutions? Not only that you seem to be implying that it is not right (timing) for Orissa to ask for an IIT now because the ruling party of the state is not aligned with the center.

Continue Reading June 21st, 2007

Which option is better IISER, NIT or IIST and why?

Someone asked the above question in Yahoo Answers India! Following was my answer.

Which option is better IISER, NIT or IIST and why?

It depends on what you want. The goal of IISERs and NISER Bhubaneswar is to focus on science and produce good scientists. If you have a choice between these institutes, you are a pretty good student. Whatever you do seriously you will be successful. Be confident of that. Heck, even graduates of private colleges in backwater towns get jobs.

So now, IISERs were made because India was falling behind in Science. In the past India had great scientists some of whom went on to get Nobel prizes. But with the IIT brand name and corresponding hype (I am an ex-IITian) every one, who can, now goes to IIT and most study engineering. Science departments, although exist in IITs, have a second class status. That has resulted in India falling behind in Science.

So the government’s aim in establishing IISERs and NISER Bhubaneswar was to create as good institutes as IITs but focused on Science.

One must realize that basic research in science later leads to developments in Engineering and Technology. So unless good talent also goes to science, the pipeline will become empty.

So, if you want to study science, you should go to IISERs or NISER. If your goal is to get a degree, and a job or to go for MBA (in IIMs) after that, then NITs are better for you.

248 comments June 21st, 2007


Calendar

June 2007
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Posts by Month

Links

Posts by Category